ComparisonsMobile development
Supabase vs Firebase for a mobile MVP
Should you use Supabase Postgres or Firebase Cloud Firestore? See how each handles offline fieldwork and shared records in a first mobile release.
Supabase Postgres- Related rows in tables
Firebase Cloud Firestore- Documents in collections
How to decide
- Choose Cloud Firestore when the first release depends on offline access to actively used documents on supported mobile clients and its conflict behavior fits the job.
- Choose Supabase Postgres when related records and SQL queries define the product. If your app must also work offline, budget time for local storage and synchronization.
Compare at a glance
| Decision | ||
|---|---|---|
| Unit of data | Related rows in tables | Documents in collections |
| Good first screen | Approvals grouped by supplier, team and project | Today’s assigned inspections on a technician’s phone |
| Working without signal | Design local storage and sync, or trial an integration such as PowerSync | Supported clients can read and write previously cached data |
| Question to resolve | Which records and changes move between the server and each device? | Can last-write-wins safely resolve concurrent changes to a document? |
| Prototype to run | Update one supplier and inspect every related purchase | Have two devices edit offline and inspect the result on reconnect |
Start with the screen your buyer depends on
Imagine a maintenance technician entering a basement with no signal. The job is to open an assigned inspection, check three items and keep the results until the phone reconnects. Now imagine a purchasing manager opening your app in the office. She needs to know which approvals are outstanding across projects, budgets and suppliers. Both are mobile apps. Their hardest screens have little in common.
This comparison covers Supabase’s Postgres database and Firebase’s Cloud Firestore. Decide which operation your first buyer will actually pay for. A checklist built around one inspection behaves differently from a report assembled from several changing records.
Choose Cloud Firestore for a field checklist
Cloud Firestore stores documents in collections. In supported Android and Apple clients, its offline persistence is enabled by default. The client can read and write locally cached data, then synchronize on reconnection. For multiple changes to one document, Firebase specifies last-write-wins behavior.
That makes a single-technician inspection worth testing in Firestore. Load the day’s assignments while connected, enter airplane mode, complete a previously opened inspection and reconnect. Also try opening an assignment the device has never loaded. An offline cache has to contain the data the technician needs.
Next, give two devices the same inspection and enter different results while both are offline. If both observations must survive, storing separate observations with their own identifiers may fit better than letting both people edit one shared result. Decide which outcome is correct before you demo the app.
Choose Supabase Postgres for a purchasing workflow
A purchase links a project, supplier, requester and approver. When one supplier changes its billing name, the change should appear wherever the app currently looks up that supplier. Supabase’s data APIs can use Postgres foreign keys to query related records together. That lets the database represent the links the purchasing manager already understands.
If that same manager must approve purchases on a plane, estimate the offline work separately. One documented option, PowerSync, synchronizes Postgres with local SQLite. The team still has to choose which records belong on each device and what to do when a local change meets a newer approval. Run a trial with your actual approval rules before promising that workflow.
Use two phones and one disputed change
Build the smallest screen that can reveal a bad choice. For the inspection, put two phones offline and have each record a result. On reconnect, ask the buyer to decide whether the screen should show the latest value, both observations or a review request.
For purchasing, change a supplier’s name and move an approver to a different team. Open yesterday’s purchase alongside today’s pending approvals. Ask which values should update and which should preserve their history. Choose the implementation that reproduces those answers with the least custom work your team will have to maintain.
Tools for this article
Sources
4 references- Cloud Firestore data model
Firebase
- Access data offline
Firebase
- Querying joins and nested tables
Supabase
- PowerSync integration for Supabase
PowerSync on Supabase