Skip to content
Founder Tools

Founder storiesEmail marketing

Nathan Barry had paying customers. He still had to find Kit’s market.

ConvertKit reached roughly $2,000 in monthly recurring revenue in its first six months. Following the next two years explains why Nathan Barry changed whom he called for a demo.

Three decisions in ConvertKit’s early years
July 2013
The six-month challenge ends near $2,000 MRR
October 2014
Barry chooses authors and starts selling directly
March 2015
The site shifts its focus to professional bloggers

Dates and monthly recurring revenue come from Barry’s published account of the business.[1]

Lessons for founders

  • A paying launch cohort can validate a purchase while leaving long-term demand open.
  • Barry’s move from authors to professional bloggers followed direct sales conversations. Those buyers were close enough to compare and specific enough to reach.
  • When testing customer groups, follow each one through a second use of the product and a renewal.

An ebook launch set the wrong clock

Nathan Barry knew how to sell a book. In an interview with Garrett Dimon, he recalled large one-off launches and the appeal of earning recurring revenue instead. His public software challenge set two constraints. He would invest $5,000 of his own money, and in six months the product would bring in $5,000 a month. Presales would help cover what the first investment could not.

The company now called Kit reached roughly $2,000 in monthly recurring revenue by the end of that first stretch. Customers had opened their wallets and the product existed. Yet in September 2014 Barry recorded just $1,337 in monthly revenue. For a founder reading those two figures years later, the intervening months matter more than the launch-day total. A new customer can buy on the strength of a promise. Renewal asks whether the work keeps coming back.

Sources123

The training program brought in beginners

Barry’s timeline describes an early attempt to grow through ConvertKit Academy. Teaching people to use the software drew customers, but by June 2014 he had concluded that the beginners it was attracting were likely to leave. He stopped promoting the program. That diagnosis came from the founder. The public figures do not tell us the retention rate for each group.

Picture two people buying the same email tool. One is putting a signup form on a first post and hopes to write again. The other needs to send an edition next Thursday to people who already expect it. Both can complete onboarding. Only one has a deadline that makes the next session necessary. A seller who measures the signup and stops there cannot tell the two jobs apart.

Sources1

A narrow audience made a sales call possible

In October 2014 Barry focused full-time on ConvertKit and started selling directly to authors. By March 2015, after more conversations, the website addressed professional bloggers. In his interview, he explained the practical benefit of a narrow audience. He could make a list of individuals who fit it and invite them to a demo. He later estimated that direct sales took the business to about $15,000 in monthly recurring revenue.

There is a small but consequential difference between choosing a niche and being able to name the people in it. A founder can spend a week polishing a description of the ideal customer without learning where one works. A short list of working publishers gives that same founder concrete questions. What did each send last week? Which task took the longest? Who would have to approve a change before next week’s edition?

Sources12

How to run the same test with your own customers

Take your last ten paying accounts and write down the actual job each one bought the product to do. For each, add the last date they used it, the next occasion they expect to need it, and whether an identifiable person owns that work. Keep a blank where you have no answer. That blank is a reason to ask for a call.

Choose two groups who describe the same problem at different frequencies. Offer both the same paid pilot. Watch the first job through to completion, then leave room for the next job to arrive on its own. Before spending on acquisition, look for the group that returned with fresh work, paid again, and could introduce another person who faces the same deadline. A handful of accounts can guide the next interviews. It takes more renewals to justify scaling the bet.

Tools for this article

  • Kit

    Group readers by the form or interest that brought them in, then compare what each group comes back to read.

Sources

3 references